Did the Visa and Mastercard Swipe Fee Settlement Get Approved on November 16?
By Yan Payments
Did the judge approve the $38 billion settlement on November 16?
No. Judge Brian Cogan held the final fairness hearing for the Visa and Mastercard interchange settlement in Brooklyn on November 16, 2026, and he didn’t rule. No decision date has been announced. The deal remains exactly where it’s been since June: preliminarily approved, not final, and still being fought over.
What actually happened at the hearing
Visa and Mastercard’s lawyers asked Cogan to grant final approval to the $38 billion settlement, arguing it delivers real relief after two decades of litigation. More than 1,000 merchants and trade groups filed formal objections, including Walmart, the National Association of Convenience Stores, and the National Retail Federation, and their lawyers got to make their case in person at the hearing.
Cogan didn’t side with either side outright. According to reporting on the hearing, he suggested that rejecting the deal could send the case, now 21 years old, back toward a long trial, a warning about the alternative rather than a ruling. That lines up with how he talked about the deal back in June, when he gave it preliminary approval and called the terms fair, reasonable, and adequate.
What would actually change if the settlement is approved
The core terms haven’t moved since the version we covered in October:
- Average credit card interchange would drop by about 0.1 percentage point for five years.
- Standard consumer credit card interchange would be capped at 1.25% for eight years.
- Merchants could surcharge Visa credit cards up to the lesser of 3% or their actual acceptance cost, loosening today’s limits.
- Merchants would get the right to decline specific card categories, including some premium rewards and commercial cards, with notice to their processor.
Debit interchange isn’t part of this. It’s set separately under federal law and this case doesn’t touch it.
Why Walmart and the convenience store industry are still fighting it
The loudest objection isn’t really about the rate cut, it’s about who actually gets to use the new right to decline cards. Walmart’s lawyers argue that letting a merchant refuse premium rewards cards is close to meaningless in practice, because customers who carry those cards will often just shop somewhere that still takes them. A big retailer can write that right into its contract and still never be able to use it without losing sales. The National Retail Federation goes further, arguing the deal leaves the networks’ practice of centrally setting interchange rates untouched and doesn’t eliminate the “honor all cards” rule that created this fight in the first place. Visa and Mastercard’s response is that merchants already have tools, like surcharging premium cards differently or discounting for cheaper ones, to shift customers away from the expensive cards without refusing them outright.
When will there actually be a ruling?
Nobody knows yet, and that’s worth sitting with rather than guessing at. Cogan took the matter under advisement with no stated deadline. Two earlier settlement attempts in this same case, one rejected on appeal in 2016 and one rejected by a different judge in 2024, both collapsed under merchant objections, so a further delay, a modified order, or an outright rejection are all still realistic outcomes here too. If he does approve it, expect an appeal to the Second Circuit; the National Association of Convenience Stores has already said it will pursue one.
What should you do about this right now
Nothing. The rate cut, the surcharge change, and the right to decline certain cards are not in effect and won’t be until a judge actually signs off, which hasn’t happened yet. If you’re building a 2027 budget, don’t bake in savings from a settlement that’s still sitting on a judge’s desk. We’ll post again the moment there’s an actual ruling, not before. For background on how this case got here, see our earlier coverage of the objections, and reach out if you want help figuring out what you’re actually paying today regardless of how this case turns out.
Sources:
- Reuters via Spokesman.com, “Visa, Mastercard urge approval of $38 billion swipe fee settlement”
- Quartz, “Visa and Mastercard pushed for final approval of $38 billion swipe fee deal”
- Electronic Payments International, “US Judge defers ruling on $38bn Visa, Mastercard swipe fee settlement”
- PYMNTS, “Visa and Mastercard Hearing Puts Premium Card Pilots on the Line”
← Back to all posts