Is Surcharging Still Worth It Heading Into the Holidays?
By Yan Payments
Is surcharging still worth it heading into the holidays?
For a lot of merchants, probably not, at least not in its plain form. New J.D. Power research shows most cardholders will walk away from a purchase rather than pay a credit card surcharge, and that risk goes up, not down, during the highest-traffic weeks of the year.
How many customers actually walk away over a surcharge?
J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Credit Card Satisfaction Study, based on surveys fielded from mid-2025 through mid-2026, found that 59% of cardholders have abandoned an in-progress purchase after learning a retailer was going to add a credit card surcharge. That’s not a one-time annoyance; it’s a majority of your card-paying customers telling researchers they’ve bailed on a checkout because of the fee.
It isn’t limited to shoppers, either. In J.D. Power’s 2026 Merchant Services Satisfaction Study, about 32% of merchants who surcharge say customers sometimes or often cancel the purchase once the fee shows up. Merchants are seeing the same abandonment their customers are reporting.
A separate J.D. Power study of small businesses, released in January 2025, found that 41% of credit card users said they’d decided not to pay by card at a business specifically because of a surcharge. That’s earlier research than the 2026 study above, but it points the same direction: surcharges push a meaningful share of customers to change how, or whether, they pay.
Put together: roughly 64% of cardholders say they’ve run into a surcharge somewhere this year, about 35% of small businesses now add one (up slightly from 34% the year before), and 81% of cardholders who’ve hit a surcharge say they’ve switched payment methods at least once to avoid paying it. Surcharging has become common enough that most shoppers have a reaction to it already formed, and for a majority of them that reaction is to leave.
Why do the holidays raise the stakes?
None of this is theoretical during a slow Tuesday in February. It matters more in the six weeks between Black Friday and New Year’s, when a shopper who bails at your checkout has a dozen other stores, in person and online, ready to take the sale instead. A 2-3% fee that might get a shrug in October can be the difference between a completed purchase and an abandoned cart when a customer is already comparing prices across three tabs.
There’s a cost on the merchant side too. J.D. Power’s data shows merchants who surcharge report satisfaction with their payment processing costs that runs about 24 points lower, on a 1,000-point scale, than merchants who don’t. Surcharging doesn’t just cost you some sales, it tends to leave merchants feeling worse about the whole arrangement.
What should California merchants check before they check Visa’s rules?
If you’re in California, the surcharge math is different from the rest of the country before you even get to customer psychology. Since SB 478, the Honest Pricing Law, took effect on July 1, 2024, adding a mandatory card fee on top of an advertised price is largely off the table for most California businesses, full stop. Restaurants have a narrow exception under SB 1524, but only if the fee is clearly disclosed on the menu alongside food and drink prices. We’ve covered the details of what’s actually allowed in our surcharge, cash discount, and dual pricing post, and on top of that, Visa still caps any surcharge at 3% or your actual cost of acceptance, whichever is lower, with enforcement that comes with real fines.
For most California merchants, that means the honest comparison isn’t surcharge versus no fee. It’s dual pricing or a cash discount, where you show the card price and the cheaper cash or ACH price side by side, against simply building the cost into one posted price. Both of those are legal, and neither one triggers the same abandonment reaction, because the customer sees the real price before they decide rather than watching a number grow at checkout.
What should you do instead this holiday season?
A few options that don’t carry the same abandonment risk:
- Build the cost into your price. A quiet, modest price increase doesn’t generate the same reaction as a fee added at the register, since customers compare the final number, not how you got there.
- Switch to dual pricing or a cash discount. You keep the ability to offset card costs, but the customer sees the real price up front instead of watching a surprise fee appear.
- If you’re outside California and still want to surcharge, keep it under 3% and disclose it clearly before checkout, not just at the final screen. Advance disclosure, on a sign at the door or on the menu, consistently performs better with customers than a fee that only appears at the register.
- Set up tap-to-pay and digital wallets well before Black Friday. A faster checkout reduces the moments where a customer has time to reconsider over a fee, surcharge or not.
If you want help setting up compliant dual pricing before the holiday rush, we can walk you through it.
This is general information, not legal advice. Surcharge rules are enforced by both state law and the card networks, and they change. Confirm the current requirements for your business before the holidays hit.
Sources: J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Credit Card Satisfaction Study (jdpower.com); J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Merchant Services Satisfaction Study (Business Wire, January 2026); J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Merchant Services Satisfaction Study (Business Wire, January 14, 2025)
← Back to all posts