Skip to main content
← Blog
4 min read

Should You Accept Bitcoin Through Square? What the Free Period Really Means

By Yan Payments

What is Square actually offering, and what will it cost?

Square is letting U.S. merchants accept Bitcoin at checkout with no processing fee through the end of 2026. Starting January 1, 2027, that fee becomes 1% per transaction. Square has gone further than just making this available: since earlier this year it’s been automatically turning Bitcoin acceptance on by default for eligible U.S. sellers, though merchants can opt out if they don’t want it.

New York merchants are excluded for now, likely tied to the state’s separate licensing requirements for cryptocurrency businesses (the BitLicense regime), which Square hasn’t fully built compliance for yet.

How does it actually work at the register?

A customer pays in Bitcoin, typically over the Lightning Network for speed, and Square converts that into dollars for you automatically, so you’re not stuck holding a volatile asset unless you choose to be. Square also gives merchants a built-in Bitcoin wallet in their dashboard, where you can choose to hold some or all of what comes in as Bitcoin instead of converting it, if you want exposure to it as an asset. That’s opt-in, not the default. The default is you get dollars, same as a card transaction.

Is the 1% fee actually a good deal starting in 2027?

Compare it to what you’re already paying. Square’s typical in-person card processing runs about 2.4% to 2.6% plus $0.15 per transaction, depending on your plan. A 1% flat fee with no per-transaction cents charge is cheaper than card processing on the fee alone, assuming volume is similar. What that comparison leaves out is volatility and customer adoption. Card payments are reliable: a $50 charge is $50. A Bitcoin payment settles into dollars at whatever Bitcoin’s price is at the moment of conversion, so the cost to you isn’t purely the 1% fee, it’s the 1% fee plus whatever slippage happens during conversion, which is usually small but not zero.

The bigger question is demand. Most consumers aren’t asking to pay in Bitcoin, and adding it won’t meaningfully grow your customer base unless you already serve a crypto-interested audience, like a tech-forward retailer, a specialty goods shop, or a business with an online crypto-native customer segment.

A worked example

Say you run a boutique doing $20,000 a month in card volume at 2.5% average, that’s about $500 a month in processing costs. If 5% of your volume, $1,000, shifted to Bitcoin through Square, you’d pay $0 in fees on that slice through the end of 2026 and $10 a month starting in 2027 at the 1% rate. That’s a real but small saving, and it only materializes if customers actually choose to pay that way. For most brick-and-mortar merchants, the realistic near-term effect of turning this on is close to zero, since adoption is the bottleneck, not the fee structure.

Who should consider turning it on?

  • Businesses with a customer base that’s already asked about crypto payments, or that skews toward tech-forward, younger, or online-first buyers
  • Online sellers who want to accept international customers without card network conversion fees
  • Anyone curious to test it, given there’s no fee and no cost to simply having the option available through the end of 2026

Who should probably skip it for now

  • Merchants in New York, since it’s not available yet
  • Any business where the operator doesn’t want to deal with explaining a new payment method to staff or customers for a feature that will see minimal use
  • Anyone uncomfortable with Bitcoin’s price swings, even temporarily, if they choose to hold any of it instead of converting to dollars immediately

Bottom line

The free period makes this a low-risk thing to turn on and watch, not a must-do business decision. If you’re on Square already, there’s little downside to enabling it before the 1% fee kicks in on January 1, 2027, as long as you set it to auto-convert to dollars so you’re not exposed to price swings you didn’t sign up for. Just don’t expect it to move your revenue much unless your customers are already asking for it.

This is general information about a payment feature, not financial or tax advice. Accepting cryptocurrency can carry separate tax reporting obligations, so check with your accountant before relying on Bitcoin conversion for any meaningful share of your revenue.

Sources: The Block, “Dorsey’s Block stock climbs to 8-month high as Square adds fee-free bitcoin payments for merchants” (theblock.co); Blockworks, “Square announces Bitcoin payments for merchants” (blockworks.co)


← Back to all posts