Skip to main content
← Blog
5 min read

What Makes a Restaurant Tip Pool Illegal? 2026's Court Rulings Show the Pattern

By Yan Payments

What makes a restaurant tip pool illegal?

Three federal rulings against restaurants landed in 2026, and together they cost one company more than 28 million dollars. Perry’s Steakhouse, which operates in Texas, Colorado, and several other states, lost on tip pooling twice in six weeks. In Texas, a federal judge found the chain had been paying tipped and non-tipped employees from the same mandatory pool between 2019 and 2022; on March 24, 2026, that turned into a 21 million dollar judgment covering 707 servers. In Colorado, a different judge ruled on February 3 that Perry’s broke the law by giving tip pool money to AM prep cooks who worked before the restaurant opened to customers, no matter what their job title said. The company settled that case for 7 million dollars.

A third case, against a Texas restaurant called Reservoir Restaurant, shows how small a mistake can be and still blow up the tip credit entirely. The restaurant had been taking a flat 1 dollar per shift fee out of servers’ tips to cover business costs. A federal court ruled in March that a single dollar of improper deduction voided the restaurant’s tip credit for the whole shift, and because the restaurant also couldn’t produce records showing how it had distributed pooled tips, its tip pool defense failed too.

Can kitchen staff or managers be in the tip pool?

Only if they regularly interact with customers. The FLSA lets a restaurant require tipped employees to pool and share tips with other employees who customarily and regularly receive tips, which generally means servers, bussers, bartenders, and hosts who deal with guests. It does not mean prep cooks, dishwashers, or line cooks working before doors open, and it never means managers or supervisors who meet the duties test for the executive exemption, even if they occasionally wait tables. The Colorado case made clear that job title doesn’t settle the question. If the AM employee is in the building prepping food before the restaurant opens to guests, courts will look at what they were actually doing, not what the schedule calls them.

Putting one ineligible employee in a mandatory pool doesn’t just create a claim for that employee. In the Texas Perry’s case, it voided the tip credit for every server who contributed to the pool, converting their wages to the full minimum wage retroactively, which is how a tip pooling mistake turns into an eight figure judgment.

Does the 80/20 rule still apply?

It’s genuinely unsettled, so don’t assume either answer. The old 80/20/30 rule, which capped how much time a tipped employee could spend on non-tipped side work before losing tip credit eligibility for that time, was vacated by the Fifth Circuit in August 2024. On October 19, 2026, the Department of Labor issued Field Assistance Bulletin 2026-1, formally withdrawing the older opinion letters the 80/20 rule had been built on. That leaves the original 1967 dual jobs regulation as the federal standard: an employee doing two genuinely different jobs, one tipped and one not, can only be paid the tip credit rate for the tipped job. Outside the Fifth Circuit (Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi), some employment lawyers are telling clients to keep following the old 80/20 proportions anyway until more courts weigh in, and several states layer on their own version of the rule regardless of what happens federally.

If you’re in California, check state law separately. California doesn’t allow a tip credit at all, tipped employees get full minimum wage before tips, so these federal tip credit fights don’t play out the same way here. We’ve covered California’s own tip handling rules before (see our SB 648 credit card tips post), but pooling and tip ownership questions still apply regardless of the tip credit issue.

What should you actually document?

A tip pool survives a lawsuit on paperwork as much as on policy. At minimum:

  • Keep a written list of which job titles are in the tip pool and why each one customarily receives tips from customers.
  • Keep time records that show when kitchen or prep staff clocked in relative to opening, if they’re ever near pooled tips.
  • Keep a record of exactly how pooled tips were distributed, by pay period, not reconstructed after a complaint is filed.
  • Confirm that no deduction, fee, or contribution requirement reduces a server below the required minimum wage after tips.
  • Post or provide written notice to customers about how service charges or tip pooling works, where your state requires one.

The Reservoir case is the clearest warning here: the restaurant’s tip pool defense failed in part because it had no records showing how tips had actually been split. Courts aren’t going to take a restaurant’s word for it after the fact.

This is general information about federal wage and hour rulings, not legal advice. Tip credit and tip pooling rules vary by state, and California has its own rules on tip ownership separate from the federal tip credit question. If you pool tips or distribute service charges, a wage and hour attorney should review your actual policy and records, not just this summary. For how we help with tip related reporting on your processing side, get in touch.

Sources


← Back to all posts