Skip to main content
← Blog
5 min read

The Federal BNPL Rule Got Pulled. What That Means If You Offer Klarna or Afterpay

By Yan Payments

Is the federal BNPL rule actually gone?

Yes, but “gone” needs a caveat: the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau withdrew its 2024 interpretive rule on buy now, pay later loans in May 2025, and has told a federal court it doesn’t currently intend to bring it back. That’s a real policy reversal, not a court ruling striking the rule down, which means a future CFPB could revisit it. For now, there’s no federal rule treating BNPL like a credit card, and the gap is being filled state by state instead.

What did the 2024 rule actually require, and why does its absence matter?

In May 2024, the CFPB issued an interpretive rule saying BNPL providers running “pay-in-four” loans, Klarna, Afterpay, Affirm, and similar products, had to follow some of the same rules that apply to credit card issuers under Regulation Z. The headline piece was dispute rights: a shopper who had a billing error or a dispute over a BNPL purchase would get the same kind of investigation and resolution process as someone disputing a credit card charge. It didn’t go as far as applying every credit card rule, things like ability-to-repay requirements stayed out of scope, but it was the first real federal floor under BNPL dispute handling.

A BNPL lender, the Financial Technology Association, sued the CFPB over the rule in October 2024, arguing the agency skipped the normal notice-and-comment process. Rather than fight it out, the CFPB told the court in March 2025 that it planned to withdraw the rule, and made that official in May 2025 as part of a larger rollback of 67 guidance documents. The lawsuit was then dropped as moot. Functionally, that means the specific dispute-rights protections the rule created no longer have a clear federal basis, though some BNPL providers may still offer similar dispute processes voluntarily or under their own card-network agreements.

What’s filling the gap: New York and Illinois’ new BNPL laws

Two states have stepped in with their own licensing regimes, aimed at the lenders, not the merchants who offer BNPL at checkout.

New York passed a BNPL licensing law in its 2025 budget, requiring BNPL lenders to get authorized by the state’s Department of Financial Services, capping interest at 16 percent, and banning unfair or excessive fees. National banks and federal credit unions are exempt. As of this writing, the law is still waiting on final implementing regulations from DFS, a proposed rule went out for public comment through September 2026, so the licensing requirement isn’t fully in force yet.

Illinois followed with its own Buy-Now-Pay-Later Loan Consumer Protection Act, signed in June 2026, which requires BNPL lenders to get licensed through the state’s Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, with full compliance generally expected by January 1, 2028. Illinois’ law is explicit that a merchant who simply offers a licensed lender’s BNPL product at checkout, without underwriting, servicing, or holding any stake in the loan itself, is exempt from the licensing requirement.

Neither law creates a new disclosure form, sign, or compliance step for the retailer or restaurant offering BNPL. The obligations land on Klarna, Afterpay, Affirm, and similar companies as lenders, not on the businesses using them as a checkout option.

Does California regulate BNPL too?

Yes, but this isn’t new. California has required BNPL “pay-in-four” lenders to hold a license under the California Financing Law since 2020, when the state settled with Afterpay, Sezzle, and Klarna over unlicensed lending. That’s five years before the current wave of state activity, and it’s the same pattern as New York and Illinois: it governs the BNPL company, not the merchant who adds a BNPL button at checkout.

Do I, as the merchant, have to do anything differently?

Not under any of these laws directly. If you’re already offering Klarna, Afterpay, or Affirm through a Clover integration or any other checkout setup, you’re not the one who needs a license, and none of this creates a new disclosure you have to hand a customer. Two things are worth doing anyway, not because a law requires it but because it protects you:

  • Confirm your BNPL provider is actually licensed to operate in the states where you do business. Partnering with an unlicensed lender is a reputational and business risk even without a law pinning liability on you directly.
  • Watch your statement for fee changes. BNPL providers facing new compliance costs in New York and Illinois may pass some of that along as higher merchant fees over time, the same pattern you’d expect with any lender absorbing new licensing overhead.

If cash flow, not financing options, is your actual problem, it’s worth asking whether faster invoicing solves it more directly than adding another financing product at checkout. We looked at what’s actually slowing merchant payments down in our piece on why invoices are taking longer to get paid, and Yan’s own invoicing tools are built around getting paid faster without adding a lending product to your checkout.

This is general information about regulatory developments, not legal advice. If you’re evaluating a specific BNPL partnership or dealing with a compliance question, talk to an attorney familiar with consumer financial law.

Sources

  • Federal Register, CFPB interpretive rule withdrawal notice, May 2025
  • Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, BNPL compliance resource page, updated July 2025
  • Kilpatrick Townsend, “CFPB Shifts Course on Buy Now, Pay Later,” 2025
  • Mayer Brown, “New York Enacts First-of-Its-Kind Law to License Buy Now Pay Later Lenders,” June 2025
  • Consumer Finance Monitor, coverage of Illinois Buy-Now-Pay-Later Loan Consumer Protection Act, June 2026
  • California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, enforcement actions against Afterpay, Sezzle, and Klarna, 2020

← Back to all posts