Skip to main content
← Blog
4 min read

Card Testing Fraud Is Up 175% This Year, and Holiday Traffic Makes It Worse

By Yan Payments

What is card testing, and why is it happening now?

Card testing is when someone runs a batch of stolen card numbers through small charges, often a dollar or less, to find out which cards are still active before using the working ones for a bigger purchase elsewhere. According to Signifyd’s 2026 State of Fraud Report, card-testing attacks rose 175% year over year comparing January through April 2026 to the same period in 2025, making it one of the fastest-growing fraud types merchants are seeing. It spikes around the holidays because higher transaction volume gives the small test charges more cover to blend in with normal traffic.

Why do small businesses get hit harder than large retailers?

Big retailers run layered fraud tools: velocity limits, device fingerprinting, machine-learning risk scoring, all tuned by dedicated fraud teams. Most small and mid-sized merchants run their checkout with CVV and basic address verification turned on, or sometimes not even that, because every extra verification step can cost a sale. Fraudsters know this and specifically target smaller, less-defended checkout pages to run their test batches before moving to the real purchase somewhere else, or on your own site once they’ve confirmed a card works.

What does a card-testing attack actually look like on your statement?

A few warning signs, usually all at once:

  • A burst of very small charges, often under $5, sometimes dozens to hundreds within a short window.
  • A sudden jump in declines, especially ones failing CVV or address verification checks.
  • Multiple attempts from the same IP address or device in a short period, often with different card numbers.
  • Charges happening at odd hours, since automated scripts don’t take breaks.

If you see a cluster of these, even if most of them declined, don’t treat it as a non-event. The declines are the test batch; the charge that succeeds is what the fraudster actually wanted.

What can you do to make your checkout a harder target?

No single setting stops card testing, but layering a few makes your site a worse target than the next one:

Defense What it does Trade-off
Require CVV Confirms the buyer has the physical card Minimal, should already be on
Address Verification Service (AVS) Matches billing address to the card on file Can add fees, occasional false declines
Velocity limits Caps attempts per IP, device, or card in a time window Needs tuning so it doesn’t block real repeat customers
CAPTCHA at checkout Slows down automated scripts Adds friction for real customers
3D Secure Shifts fraud liability and adds a verification step More friction, usually reserved for higher-risk orders

A reasonable baseline for most small merchants heading into the holidays: keep CVV and AVS on, set a velocity limit of a handful of attempts per IP per hour, and turn on 3D Secure for orders above whatever dollar threshold makes sense for your business, rather than every transaction.

What do you do if you catch an attack in progress?

Act within the hour, not the next business day. Temporarily tighten your velocity limits or pause the affected product page or checkout flow. Review the batch of declined and approved charges together so you know which card numbers got through. Contact your payment processor so they can flag the activity and watch for related chargebacks. Once the pattern stops, you can ease the limits back to normal; the point is to close the window while the attack is active, not to leave stricter settings on indefinitely.

Does this mean your losses go up 175% too?

No, and that distinction matters when you’re deciding how much to invest in defenses. The 175% figure measures the growth in attack attempts across Signifyd’s merchant network, not a 175% rise in actual dollar losses. Most card-testing charges are small and many get declined outright. The real cost shows up less in the test charges themselves and more in the fraudulent purchases that follow once a working card is found, plus the processing fees and potential chargebacks tied to each attempt.

Holiday traffic is exactly the cover fraudsters are counting on this month. If you haven’t checked your checkout’s CVV and AVS settings since you first set them up, this is a good week to do it, before Black Friday and Cyber Monday volume gives a test batch somewhere to hide.

This is general information, not a guarantee against fraud. Talk to your payment processor about the specific velocity and verification settings available on your account.

Sources:

  • Signifyd, 2026 State of Fraud Report
  • Retail Dive, “Signifyd’s 2026 State of Fraud Report Reveals a Fundamental Shift in Ecommerce Fraud”
  • CPA Practice Advisor, “Report Shows a Fundamental Shift in Ecommerce Fraud”
  • Forte, “Beat the Numbers Game: Guard Against Card Testing Fraud”

← Back to all posts